An Analysis of Sharia and Conventional Shares’ System at Indonesia Stock Exchange

Main Article Content

Hersugondo Hersugondo
Cholimatul Sadiyah
Eka Handriani
Herry Subagyo
Sih Darmi Astuti


There are lots of alternative investing. It is started from investment real assets, securities, from conventional and manifold sharia. Islamic Capital market and conventional have some type securities which have different risk level of risks. A stock is one of securities among other securities that have the high level of risk. One of the risks that exists in the stock is fluctuations price, it is commonly called as volatility. The aim of this research is to identifiy the risk of sharia stock and conventional stock in Indonesia Stock Exchange (BEI) by using Jakarta Islamic Indekx (JII) and LQ45 Indeks variabels. In our research, we use time series started on 1 January 2015 to 10 October 2016 from yahoo finance with ARCH/GARCH and EGARCH models processed by Eview 8. Based on research finding with GARCH and EGARCH, this research tends to EGARCH. The fist finding shows that volatility stock JII lower, 0,075 than LQ45 0,0316. If volatility is higher, it means the stability degree lower. Both of those stocks are dominated by bad news and good news. Between JII and LQ45, the news respon is higher on LQ45. It means the volatility risk impact higher on LQ45. The third finding is the JII forecasting results through EGARCH has refrection proportion JII has smaller 0,194 than LQ45 0,678. It means that JII volatility is lower than LQ45.

Article Details



Anton. 2006. An Analysis of Volatility Model of Stock Return (Case Study at LQ 45 Shares in Jakarta Stock Exchange). Thesis. Semarang: Diponegoro University Graduate Program.
Beik, Irfan Syauqi and Fatmawati, Sri Wulan.2014. The Influence of Sharia International Stock Price Index and Macro Economic Variables against Jakarta Islamic Index. Faculty of Economics and Management. Bogor: Bogor Agricultural University. Vol. VI, No. 2, July 2014
Fadillah, Rifki Febi Nur.2010. An Analysis of Risk-Purchase Balance (Risk-return trade off) Shares between Jakarta Islamic index and LQ45 in Indonesia Stock Exchange. Thesis.
Hasbullah, Endang Soeryana, Mohd, Ismail Bin, Mamat, Mustafa, et al. 2013. The Performance Analysis of Multiple Sharia Shares Using a Non-Constant Volatility Model. Stastistika, Vol.13, No. 1, p 25-31. May 2013.
Hersugondo, Robiyanto, Wahyudi. S., And Muharam, H. 2015. The World Oil Price Movements And Stock Returns In Several Southeast Asia’s Capital Markets. International Journal Business and Economic Research. Vol. 13, No. 2: 527-534.
H. Hersugondo, R. Robiyanto, Wahyudi. S., D.P. Irene Rini. 2016. The Test Of Day Of The Week Effect And Turn-Of-Month Effect By Using A Garch Approach: Evidence From Indonesia Capital Market. International Journal Economic Research, 13(1): 153-163
Kurniawan, Rizki Dwi and Asandimitra, Nadia. 2014. A Comparison Analysis of Sharia Stock Performance and Conventional Stock Performance. Journal of Management Science. Vol. 2, No. 4. October 2014
Lestari, Ayu. 2013. A Comparative Analysis of Risk and Return of Sharia Shares and Conventional Shares (Case Study on JII Stock Index and LQ-45 Index). Riau: S1 State Islamic University, Management Program, Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau.
Maskur, Ali. 2009. The Volatility of Shares Price between Conventional Shares and Sharia. The Dynamics of Finance and Banking, August 2009.Vol. 1, No. 2, p. 82-94.ISSN: 1979-4874
Mukmin, Amirul and Firmansyah. 2015. A Comparative Analysis of Stock Price Index Volume JCI and JII. Journal of Economics and Banking. Vol.3, No. 1, April 2015, p.69-84
Nachrowi D, nachrowi and Hardinus, Usman. A Popular Approach and Practical Econometrics for Economic and Financial Analysis. LPFEUI. 2006. p. 355.
Nastiti, Khoiru Liummah Ayu and Suharsono Agus. 2012. A Volatility Analysis Company Shares Go Public with ARCH-GARCH Motion. A Journal of Science and Arts. Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences. Sepuluh Nopember Institute of Technology (ITS). Vol.1, No. 1, p. 259-264 (Sept. 2012). ISSN: 2301-928X
Rosyida, Ajeng Gama and Mawardi, Imron. 2015. The Comparison of Return, Risk and Coefficient of Variance on Sharia Shares and Non-Sharia Shares in Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) Period 2011-2013.Vol. 2, No. 4, April 2015
Samsul, Mohamad. 2006. Capital Market and Portfolio Management. Jakarta: Erlangga.
Soedewi, Srie and Purqon, Acep. 2015. A Volatility Analysis of Five Different Stock Sectors on Compass Index 100 by ARCH-GARCH Method. Faculty of Math and Science. Institute of Technology Surabaya.
Sunariyah.2004. Introduction to Capital Market Knowledge. Yogyakarta: UPP AMP YKPN
Sutedi, Ardian. (2011). Pasar Modal Syariah. Cet. 1. Jakarta: Sinar Grafika.
Widuhung, Sisca Debyol. 2014. The Comparison of Return and Investment Risk on Sharia and Gold Shares. Journal of Al-Azhar Indonesia Series of Social Institutions.Vol.2, No.3, March 2014